September 26, 2004

Comparing the Kryptonite problem to DMCA

Kryptonite locks can be opened with a Bic pen and hard shove (more detail on that, if you want it). George Hotelling draws a parallel between this and DRM/DMCA.

...Let's pretend that the law treated the Bic pen vulnerability the way it treats decrypting DVDs.

First, the person who discovered the flaw has his home raided by police and goes through two trials in as many years. Next, everyone linking to the video is sued, although the New York Times is spared. Finally once all the lawsuits had gone through their motions, Kryptonite congratulates itself on a job well done. Of course the don't fix the lock, but since it can silence anyone who talks about how to break the lock they don't need to.

Hmmm... does this sound like anyone to you?

Posted by Casper at September 26, 2004 01:21 AM
Comments